Ill-treatment
in detention
HRDs are one of the groups at greatest risk of torture and ill-treatment. Their efforts to document
and denounce human rights violations, as well as their ability to mobilise communities, frequently
arouse the wrath of the authorities, who retaliate by inflicting both physical and mental suffering
on them. According to data collected by OMCT’s Global Torture Index, torture and ill-treatment
of HRDs is ‘very frequent’ in countries like Belarus and ‘frequent’ in Tunisia and Ethiopia – to
mention some countries that were also included in the pilot phase of SOS-Defenders.
When defenders are in detention, the risk of torture and ill-treatment is even greater, as they
are often subjected to harsh detention regimes and deprived of the due process guarantees
commonly offered to ordinary citizens. When dealing with HRDs, repressive governments use
not detention as punishment but apply punishment in detention in the form of torture and illtreatment.
Among the 93 cases of HRDs arbitrarily detained in 2024 documented by SOS-Defenders, the
most reported forms include:
• Beatings by prison officers (such as in the cases of Vital Chopik in Belarus
and of Bakhrom Khamroev and Fail Alsynov in Russia);
•D
eprivation of contact with families (for example, in the cases of Houra
Nikbakht, Nasrin Hasani and Samaneh Asghari in Iran); and
• Denial of medical care (such as in the case of Mohammad
Davari in Iran).
ill-treatment
These are just a few examples. There is reason to believe
that violations against HRDs in detention are significantly
underreported, both for fear of suffering further reprisals and
because of the inaccessibility of many detention facilities to
external monitors and civil society organisations.
10. The Global Torture Index is available at: https://www.omct.org/en/global-torture-index
11